文章基本信息

标题：Deliberative research as a tool to make value judgements
本地全文：下载
作者：Tania Burchardt
期刊名称：Distributional Analysis Publications
印刷版ISSN：1352-2469
出版年度：2012
卷号：2012
出版社：Suntory Toyota International Centres for Economics and Related Disciplines
摘要：The ‘deliberative turn’ in democratic theory has generated a wealth of deliberative experiments. The purpose of deliberation as a research technique (as opposed to policymaking or public consultation) is distinctive: to uncover the public’s informed, considered, and collective view on a normative question. In the social science context, this often arises in relation to research on poverty, well-being and inequality, where there is a need to define and justify the thresholds and concepts adopted on a deeper basis than convention alone can offer. This paper compares deliberative research to more traditional methods of studying the values of the general public, such as in-depth interviewing, attitudinal surveys, and participatory approaches, and reveals that deliberative designs involve a number of assumptions, including a strong fact/value distinction, an emphasis on ‘outsider’ expertise, and a view of participants as essentially similar to each other rather than defined by socio-demographic differences. Normative decisions permeate the design and implementation of deliberative research, so while it has the potential to provide uniquely considered, insightful and welljustified answers to the problem of defining a collective position on key questions in social science, transparency at all stages of the process is essential.
关键词：Deliberative research; value judgements; capability approach; inequality;research design.