摘要:Biofuels from land-rich tropical countries may help displace foreign petroleum imports for
many industrialized nations, providing a possible solution to the twin challenges of energy
security and climate change. But concern is mounting that crop-based biofuels will
increase net greenhouse gas emissions if feedstocks are produced by expanding
agricultural lands. Here we quantify the 'carbon payback time' for a range of
biofuel crop expansion pathways in the tropics. We use a new, geographically
detailed database of crop locations and yields, along with updated vegetation
and soil biomass estimates, to provide carbon payback estimates that are more
regionally specific than those in previous studies. Using this cropland database,
we also estimate carbon payback times under different scenarios of future crop
yields, biofuel technologies, and petroleum sources. Under current conditions,
the expansion of biofuels into productive tropical ecosystems will always lead to
net carbon emissions for decades to centuries, while expanding into degraded or
already cultivated land will provide almost immediate carbon savings. Future
crop yield improvements and technology advances, coupled with unconventional
petroleum supplies, will increase biofuel carbon offsets, but clearing carbon-rich land
still requires several decades or more for carbon payback. No foreseeable changes
in agricultural or energy technology will be able to achieve meaningful carbon
benefits if crop-based biofuels are produced at the expense of tropical forests.