文章基本信息

标题：Methodological pluralism as a vehicle of qualitative generalization
本地全文：下载
作者：Kim Christian Schrøder
期刊名称：Participations
印刷版ISSN：1749-8716
出版年度：2012
卷号：9
期号：2
页码：798-825
出版社：Department of Theatre, Film and Television Studies, University of Wales
摘要：This article proposes an innovative framework for making analytical generalizations in qualitative research. In order to achieve this purpose it contends that the multi-methodological strategy, now readily accepted in many qualitative quarters, of mixing qualitative and quantitative methods by applying them one after the other in a sequential manner can be supplemented by a multimethod strategy which combines qualitative and quantitative in an integrative manner which synthesizes the two approaches into one empirical design. The article argues that by combining qualitative and quantitative analysis and interpretation of the same data material using the Q-methodological approach it is possible to overcome interpretive opacity – always the Achilles’ heel of an exclusively qualitative procedure of generalization. The proposal is substantiated empirically by applying the integrative approach to a study of how citizen-consumers navigating in the cross-media news landscape can be represented in a typology of seven news media repertoires. The last part of the article discusses two different epistemological lenses for methodological pluralism termed the ‘different knowledges’ perspective and the ‘common knowledge’ perspective; it is the latter of these, inspired by critical realism, which makes it possible to build a sound epistemological foundation for the multi-method endeavor.
关键词：qualitative and quantitative methods; generalization; Q-methodology; typology; epistemology; news; reception