Thermal Regime Aspects when Grinding Rubber Rolls for Paper Industry.
Valea, Petre ; Strajescu, Eugen
Thermal Regime Aspects when Grinding Rubber Rolls for Paper Industry.
1. Introduction
The heat generated by the cutting processes is a consequence of the
material deformation, chips segmentation and removal, as well as of the
friction between the chips and the tool and between the tool and the
machined surface. The heat resulting from this main is shared by the
tool, chips, blank and the environment.
Thermal phenomena, which inevitably accompany the grinding process
of the rubber parts, has a significant influence on the workpiece
accuracy and a smaller one on the cutting tool wear and the deformation
process. Increased heat in the contact area between the grinding wheel
and the machined surface can cause errors that can lead to grinding
surface degradation (pinching, burns, cracks, cuts).
In printing and textile industry a wide variety of rollers are used
with a steel core and an overlying rubber coating. The main industrial
application of this rollers are printing and deflection processes. The
surface quality, roundness and concentricity accuracy that are required
are in the range of a few hundredths of a millimetre. This level of
precision is typically achieved by external cylindrical grinding.
processes.
In the case of the rubber grinding processes, it is recommended
that the temperature in the cutting area to not exceed a limit of
15[degrees]C and that an abundant cutting fluid flow rate (80-100 l /
min) to be used. Also, the scientific literature [1,2, 3] recommends
that for every 10 mm of the abrasive wheel height is useful to provide a
cooling fluid flow rate of 5..8 l/min. The higher the hardness of the
abrasive material used is and the denser the wheel structure is, a
higher cutting fluid flow rate must be used. In order to improve the
quality of the coolant it is necessary to introduce certain additives,
as well as the elimination of the impurities using the filters and
separators.
Taking into account the above considerations, the rigorous control
of the temperature developed in the cutting area is required for the
grinding of the hard rubber parts. The cutting parameters must be
carefully chosen as to ensure during the cutting process, in the contact
area between the grinding wheel and the rubber workpiece, temperatures
lower than the rubber thermal degradation temperature.
2. Literature review
The grinding process is the high temperature characterized by
arising in zone of the cutting, promoting appearance heat defect on
processed surface, reducing working factors of the details [18]. There
is poor scientific literature on the grinding processes of the rubber
rollers used in the paper industry. Most of the scientific work in this
field[4,5] deals with the machinability by grinding of the parts used in
metallurgy and paper industry. The rubber covered rollers used in the
paper industry are subjects of special inspections due to the demanding
precision required in terms of surface finishing, roundness,
concentricity, static and dynamic balance [4,20]
The literature review of the cutting processes of rubber parts
deals mainly with the turning process of small dimension parts [6]. The
grinding processes of the large rollers covered by hard rubber (usually
85-92 Shore) are poor documented in the scientific literature. Stetiu
[3] presents aspects of the choice of grinding wheels, abrasive liquids,
especially for difficult grinding materials such as rubber, cork, felt,
skin, wood, asbestos, and heat-sensitive materials - such as stainless
steels, high-alloy steels. Also, firms that are specialized in machining
parts for the paper industry give some technical recommendations and
manufacturing solutions for grinding rubber rollers [4,20,21]
3. Identify the problem
The purpose of the research is to identify the problems that occur
in the case of hard rubber grinding, in order to issue reliable
technical solutions for avoiding thermal machining errors when grinding
rubber covered rollers for the paper industry. In order to avoid thermal
deformations an adequate thermal regime in the cutting area during the
grinding process must be maintained.
The main technological objectives that must be considered when
rough grinding rubber parts are obtaining the prescribed roughness,
assuring the integrity of the machined surfaces (avoiding burns, cracks,
pinching, scratches, and residual stresses) and the prescribed
geometrical and shape precision. Rubber is being considered a highly
thermal sensitive material for mechanical machining. Precision grinding
processes for rubber rollers depends on a number of factors like machine
stiffness, genmetrical and cinematical precision, tool type and
precision, cutting conditions, etc One of the main factors that can
aaffect the grinding process of rubber rollers precision is the thermal
regime durring cutting.
Grinding of rubber is considered a difficult process, because of
the build-up of rubber chips on the face of the grinding wheel and
because of the thermal deformations of the part as a result of the
cutting heat generated. Also, the friction generated by the abrasive
wheel- rubber part contact, as the wheel cuts, combined with the poor
thermal conductivity of rubber, leads to excessive heat generation. This
can lead to wheel cracking and sometimes even breakage. For this
reasons, the abrasive industry has often been hesitant to supply
grinding wheels for this particular application.
The paper deals with optimizing the cutting parameters of the
grinding process of large dimension hard rubber covered rolls with
different or unburned sleeves with porous abrasive wheels. If the rubber
covered rollers have not been properly grinding (resulting a crown
deflections of k = 1,420 mm on the rubber sheath rollers, [PHI] = 800
mm, see Figures 1) then the laminate strip breaks and the whole
technological process is affected.
4. The thermal regime of rubber grinding
The manufacturing process grinding is characterized by high thermal
loads caused by large contact areas and a high number of grain cuts as
well as negative chip angle [19]. For the study of the thermal regime of
the rubber grinding process, the infrared thermography method was used.
This method consists in the remote detection of infrared radiation
emitted by a product under examination and the transformation of the
information gathered by point-to-point scanning into a visible image on
which temperatures can be highlighted at any point. (See Figures 2, 3
and 4).
A thermovision camera, model FLIR type E-45 from Vrancart Adjud
company from Romania was used.
5. Experimental method
Taking into account the recommendations from technical literature
[7-11] and the cinematic possibilities of the Mockba Model XH-193H8
Grinding Roll Machine from the Mechanical Workshop of Vrancart Company,
Adjud, Vrancea, (See Figures 6 and 7) the experiments were carried out
by modifying the depth of cut [a.sub.p] [mm], the longitudinal feed rate
[f.sub.l] [mm/min] and the workpiece speed (roller speed) [v.sub.p]
[m/s]. The chosen values for these machining parameters are shown in
Table 1.
The experiments were carried out with the purpose to draw some
pertinent conclusions about the optimal cutting parameters for grinding
large rubber rollers in terms of thermal cutting regime.
Super porous abrasives wheels are successfully used for the process
of grinding rubber rollers used for the paper industry [4,12]. The super
porous abrasive wheels with the following dimensions: 600 x 304,5 x 80
(D x d x H) and the hardness H were used on the grinding machine
XO-193H8 Mosckba for grinding of large rubber rollers. The grinding
wheels used were: 33A46J10V for roughing and 22C80J10V for finishing.
We mention that the same types of abrasive wheels are used for the
grinding of rubber parts in other paper factories than the one where the
research have been done, for example SC Ambro SA Suceava and SC Ecopaper
SRL Zarnesti (See Figures 8 and 9).
6. Design of experiments--DOE
Design of experiments (DOE) is an important statistical technique
for improving product quality and solving production problems.
The plan chosen for the experiments is shown in Table 3.
In this paper, three input independent variables and two levels
(-1) and (+1) were chosen for the variance of the parameters and the
prediction of the optimal values, as shown in Table 2. The symbolization
used was: (-1) for the lower level of a factor; (+1) for the upper level
of a factor. According to this convention, the matrix of experiences can
be written, Table 3 and 4.
7. Workpiece temperature analysis during grinding
In the development of the present research it was considered
necessity to determine the correlation between the cutting parameters:
the workpiece speed [v.sub.p] [m / s], the longitudinal feed [f.sub.l]
[mm / min] and the depth of cut [a.sub.p] [mm] over the part
temperature. For the workpiece temperature, a regression function was
determined with a form of polytrophic equation [13]:
T = [C.sub.T][v.sup.[alpha].sub.p][f.sup.[beta].sub.l][a.sup.[gamma].sub.p] (1)
Another indicator of a good cooling in the grinding process is the
temperature of the liquid after the process: the lower the liquid
temperature is, the cooling is considered to be optimal [3].
The cutting liquid that is most commonly used is the aqueous
solution with small amount of soda ash, soap. When finishing grinding,
the cutting fluid chemical composition may influence the surface
quality. It is recommended to keep a clean coolant during machining. The
washing capacity of the coolant influences the finishing grinding; in
this sense it is recommended to use liquids having a high washing
capacity. [14-17] [2.sup.3] = 8 full factorial experiments plan was
performed.
For the considered regression equation: T = f([v.sub.p], [f.sub.l],
[a.sub.p]), after the experiments were carried out the experimental data
was processed with a specialized software, MINITAB 17 free version. For
the experimental values obtained, the software returned the following
temperature variation law (regression equation):
T = 8,3903 x [v.sub.p.sup.0,27352] x [f.sub.l.sup.0,105955] x
[a.sub.p.sup.0,03992] (2)
As we can see, the influence of the workpiece speed had manifested
a higher influence on the workpiece temperature compared to the
longitudinal cutting feed and the cutting depth.
With the software MINITAB 17 free version, the workpiece
temperature variation with the longitudinal cutting feed f [mm/min] and
the cutting depth [mm] graph was plotted (See Figure 10). There can be
observed a rise in temperature with the increase of the cutting depth
and the longitudinal cutting feed.
Figure 11 shows the variation of the temperature in relation with
the workpiece speed [v.sub.p] [m / s] and the longitudinal cutting feed
[f.sub.l] [mm / min]. An increase in workpiece temperature can be
observed with the increase of the workpiece speed [v.sub.p] [m / s] and
the longitudinal feed rate [f.sub.l] [mm / min]. As we can see the
cutting speed exercises a higher influence over the workpiece
temperature.
Figure 12 shows the temperature variation according to the
workpiece speed [v.sub.p] [m / s] and the cutting depth [mm]. There can
be observed an increase in temperature with the workpiece speed increase
and the workpiece depth [mm] increase.
Figure 13 and 14 show the factors main effects and factors
interactions on the workpiece temperature variation. The three input
parameters chosen for the study have a negative influence on the
workpiece temperature during grinding. The main effects plot gives the
optimal combination of grinding process parameters for minimal workpiece
temperature during machining. The optimal combination of parameters is
found to be ([v.sub.p] - (-1), [f.sub.l] - (-1), [a.sub.p] - (-1)),
lower-levels of workpiece speed, feed rate and depth of cut. Also, the
main effect plot throws some light on the significance of the parameters
on the system response. The slope of the main effect plot for each
parameter reveals the intensity of the influence of the parameter. The
plot having higher inclination will have higher influence. From Figure
13, it can be observed that the factor workpiece speed is more
significant while the factor depth of cut has the lowest significance.
Interactions between the parameters were studied by using
interaction plot drawn and shown in Figure 14. As expected, the
interaction between worpiece cutting speed and the longitudinal cutting
feed has the greatest influence over the workpiece temperature during
grinding.
8. Regresion analysis
The Minitab output for the regression is presented below:
Equation
T[C] = 8.3903 * 'vp [m/s]' [disjunction] 0.27352 *
'fl [mm/min]' [disjunction] 0.105955 * 'ap [mm]'
[disjunction] 0.0399203
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Estimate SE Estimate 95% CI
[c.sub.T] 8.39030 1.21337 (5.61102, 12.4962)
[alpha] 0.27352 0.04128 (0.15928, 0.3887)
[beta] 0.10596 0.02581 (0.03440, 0.1779)
[gamma] 0.03992 0.01509 (-0.00193, 0.0819)
T [C] = [c.sub.T] * 'vp [m/s]' [disjunction] [alpha] *
'fl [mm/min]' [disjunction] [beta] * 'ap [mm]'
[disjunction] [gamma]
Summary
Iterations 6
Final SSE 0.363791
DFE 4
MSE 0.0909479
S 0.301576
In the section Parameter Estimates there are given the points
estimated for the parameters and the 95% confidence intervals. We
consider this to be a reasonable range that implies significance.
The value 0.301576 for the Standard error of the regression S
indicates that the observed temperature values fall a standard distance
(roughly an average absolute distance) of 0.301576 units from the fitted
mobility values determined with the regression equation.
The normal probability plot shows an approximately linear pattern
consistent with a normal distribution. (See Figure 15) The plot of
residuals versus the fitted values shows a random pattern, which
suggests that the residuals have constant variance. (See Figure 16)
Therefore, the regression equation obtained "(2)" can be
consider adequate for analyzing the thermal regime of the rubber
workpiece during grinding with abundant cutting fluid flow rate. The
regression model specify correctly the relationship between the
response-workpiece temperature and the predictors--workpiece speed,
longitudinal cutting feed f [mm / min] and the cutting depth [mm].
According to the regression equation obtained, the optimal
conditions that can assure a minimal workpiece temperature during
grinding and therefore smaller thermal deflection of the rubber rollers
machined with abundant lubricant flow rate (100 l / min), imply using
smaller values for the cutting parameters, especially for the workpiece
speed [v.sub.p] [m/s].
9. Conclusion
This paper purpose was to investigate the influence of cutting
conditions over the workpiece temperature durring rubber rollers
grinding process. The process thermal regim and esspecialy the workpiece
temperature has a significant influence over the grinding process
ability to produce the round, concentric rubber rolls with tight
tolerances and free from surface inconsistencies and variations. High
cutting temperature can lead to thermal deflections that result in crown
shaped external diameter rollers.
That is why it is very important to analyse and prevent temperature
variations on the roll face durring machining. By analyzing the measured
temperatures of the workpiece (that were in the range of 9-12
[degrees]C) during the grinding tests that were carried out it was found
that the abundant lubricant flow rate (100 l / min) can limit and
eliminate much of the amount of heat released in the cutting zone.
For the specific cutting conditions used in the experiments, the
surface quality obtainedwas the one prescribed and no burn, cracks or
other defects could be observed on the machined surfaces. It has also
been found that the influence of the workpiece (the roller) speed
manifests a greater influence over the workpiece temperature during
grinding, compared to the longitudinal cutting feed and the cutting
depth.
Since the grinding process of rubber parts is a difficult
industrial application (because of the thermal sensitivity of the
machined material), it is necessary to continue the researches with
higher cutting speeds and even high flow rates for the cutting coolant,
or using different cooling methods in order to establish the proper
conditions necessary for grinding rubber covered rollers with high
productivity and accuracy .
Also, as a further research direction, it is proposed to continue
the grinding of hard rubberin a cryogenic medium (liquid nitrogen) with
higher cutting speeds with the purpose of increasing process
productivity.
DOI: 10.2507/28th.daaam.proceedings.121
10. References
[1] Vlase, A. &Gheorghiu, S.,(1995). Processing technologies on
grinding machines, Technical Publishing House,ISBN 973-31-0629-1,
Bucharest, Romania
[2] Vlase, A., Balan, I.R &Vlase, B.G., (2011). Design of
technologies on grinding machines, Printech PublishingHouse,ISBN
978-606-521-729-4, Bucharest, Romania
[3] Stetiu, M., Lazarescu, I.D., Oprean, C., &Stetiu, G.,
(1994). Theory and practice of cutting tools, vol. Ill, Design of
cutting tools (II), University of Sibiu Publishing House, Sibiu, Romania
[4] Negrea, I &Kaima, A., (1987) Abrasive bodies for grinding
cylinders, Edited by Carbochim Cluj-Napoca, ClujNapoca, Romania
[5] Axinte, D.A., (1996), The correlation between the grinding
process and the rolling mill grinding machine, PhDDissertation,
University of Galati, Faculty of Mechanics, Galati, Romania
[6] Popescu, I., (1998). Research on cutting of non-ferrous and
non-metallic materials), Reprography of the Universityof Craiova,
Craiova, Romania
[7] Alexis, J., (1999). Taguchi Method in Industrial Practice -
Experience Plans, Technical Publishing House, ISBN973-31-1352-2,
Bucharest, Romania
[8] Musca, G., Amarandei, D. & Ionescu, R., (1998),
Experimenting, modeling and optimizing products and processes,Technical
Publishing House, Chisinau, Moldavia
[9] Ionescu, R. &Amarandei, D., (2004). Experiment Planning -
Efficiency and Quality,A.G.I.R.PublishingHouse,ISBN 973-8466-43-1,
Bucharest, Romania
[10] ***Roller Grinding Machine Technical Paper model XO-193H8,
(1982). Mockba, URSS
[11] ***Grinding machines, (1982).Stankoimport, Moscou, URSS, 1982
[12] ***Catalog of abrasive products Carbochim, (2015).
Cluj-Napoca, Romania
[13] Strajescu, E., (2004). The roughness of cutting tools,
BrenPublishing House, ISBN 973-648-366-5, Bucharest, Romania
[14] Savin, I.M., (2006). Cooling - spray lubrication in metal
cutting, PerformanticaPublishing House, ISBN 978-973730- 321-9, Iasi,
Romania,
[15] Barbulescu, V., (1973). Rectifiers - Quality and quality
control of machined parts by grinding, no.3, Ministry of Heavy Machinery
Construction, Office of Documentation and Technical Publications,
Bucharest, Romania
[16] Ciolacu, F.G., (2006). Managing the technological fluids for
cutting, Sitech Publishing House, ISBN 973-746-3382, Craiova, Romania
[17] Stefanescu, I., (2011). Improved machinability by using fluids
for cutting, SitechPublishing House, Craiova,ISBN 978-606-11-1873-1,
Craiova, Romania
[18] Starshev, D. (2008), Influence of the mode of the cooling
under grinding on quality of surface layer.(Report)" Annals of
DAAAM & Proceedings. DAAAM International Vienna.
[19] Schneider, M.; Klein, F. & Abt, C. (2010), Reductionof
cooling lubrifications in the grinding process, 7th International DAAAM
Baltic Conference
[20] Practical Roll Techniques: Grinding & Balancing, Valmet
technical paper series, september 2013,
http://www.valmet.com/globalassets/media/downloads/white-papers/roll-services/wpr_grindandbalance.pdf, Accessed on: 2017-06-10
[21] The polishing of rubber covered rollers, Roller Manufacturing
Articles, Rollertech,
http://www.rollertech.co.uk/articles/polishing.html Accessed on:
2017-06-10
Caption: Fig. 1. The rubber rollers crown deflection, k=1,420 mm
Caption: Fig. 2. Workpiece temperature measurement with FLIR-E45
Caption: Fig. 3. Temperature measured with the FLIR-E45
thermographic camera at short cooling fluid interruption
Caption: Fig. 4. Temperature measuring with the FLIR-E45
thermographic camera
Caption: Fig. 5. Rubber rollers grinding process using abundant
cooling liquid at SC Vrancart SA Adjud, Vrancea
Caption: Fig. 6. Front view of the rubber rollers grinding process
Caption: Fig. 7. Grinding of rubber roller at SC Ambro SA Suceava
Caption: Fig. 8. Grinding machine at SC Ecopaper SRL Zarnesti
Caption: Fig. 9. 3D surface plot for effect of longitudinal cutting
feed [f.sub.l] [mm/min] and depth of cut [a.sub.p] [mm] on workpiece
temperature T[[sup.0]C]
Caption: Fig. 10. Surface plot of T [[sup.0]C] versus workpiece
speed vp [m/s], longitudinal advance fl [mm/min]
Caption: Fig. 11. 3D surface plot for effect of workpiece speed
[v.sub.p] [m/s] and depth of cut [a.sub.p] [mm] on workpiece temperature
T [[sup.0]C]
Caption: Fig. 12. Main effects plot for T [sup.0]C
Caption: Fig. 13. Interaction plot for T [sup.0]C.
Caption: Fig. 14. Normal probability plot for T [C]
Caption: Fig. 15. Residuals versus the fits plot for T [C]
Table 1. The grinding conditiones
Machine-tools: the Mockba model XH-193H8 grinding roll machine [10]
Abrasive wheel: Super-porous stone 600 x 304,5 x 80
(D x d x H), H [12]
Cutting parameters Values U.M.
Depth of processing [a.sub.p] 0,025; 0,100 [mm]
Longitudinal feed [f.sub.l] 111; 250 [mm/min]
The speed of workpiece, [v.sub.p] 0,33; 0,55 [m/s]
Observations:
--the grinder operations were done
with coolant
(See Figures 6 and 7)
Table 2. Standard 23 full factorial design matrix
Factors
Experiment The speed Longitudinal Depth of
number of cutting feed cut
workpiece [f.sub.l] [mm] [a.sub.p] [mm]
[v.sub.p] [m/s]
1. + 1 +1 +1
2. +1 +1 -1
3. +1 -1 +1
4. +1 -1 -1
5. -1 +1 +1
6. -1 +1 -1
7. -1 -1 +1
8. -1 -1 -1
Table 3. Selection of the independent variables and their levels
Factor\NivelLevel [v.sub.p] [m/s] [f.sub.l][mm/min] [a.sub.p]
[mm]
-1 0,33 111 0,025
+1 0,55 250 0,100
Table 4. Experimental plan with assign parameters and response values
Factors
Exp. The speed Longitudinal Depth of
num.r of cutting feed cut
workpiece [f.sub.l] [mm/min] [a.sub.p] [mm]
[v.sub.p] [m/s]
1. 0,50 250 0,100
2. 0,50 250 0,025
3. 0,50 111 0,100
4. 0,50 111 0,025
5. 0,33 250 0,100
6. 0,33 250 0,025
7. 0,33 111 0,100
8. 0,33 111 0,025
Temperature
T [[sup.0]C]
Exp.
num.r
1. 12
2. 11
3. 10,5
4. 10
5. 9,8
6. 9,6
7. 9,5
8. 9
COPYRIGHT 2018 DAAAM International Vienna
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.