Training and Development Issues: Evidence form Polytechnic Libraries in Ghana.
Asante, Edward ; Alemna, A.A.
Training and Development Issues: Evidence form Polytechnic Libraries in Ghana.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Academic libraries are set up in academic setting solely to support
teaching, learning and research. They are the core of the academic set
up because; they stock information resource that is relevant to the
various disciplines being pursued in the institution. A Polytechnic
library is a library set up by the institution to support learning,
teaching and research. This is mainly through collaboration with faculty
for the provision of recommended and relevant text to support the
various disciplines in the institution. A typical Polytechnic library is
equivalent to that of a tertiary library because the Polytechnic is a
tertiary institution (Ministry of Education, 2003).The personnel in the
Polytechnic library environment are professionals of higher academic
qualification in library science and librarianship ranging from
Doctorate, Masters to Diploma and Certificate levels.
According to Castelyn (2007) all libraries aim to have efficient
staff in order to provide a good library service to the public they hope
to serve, whether that readership is using a public, university, school
or private library. Training and development therefore, is of the utmost
importance in the library field, although each library organization must
decide for itself what it means by a desired state of efficiency, as
requirements will alter from library to library and country to country.
However, the training and development should be designed to ensure
efficient performance to the dual benefit of the library system and the
users. Training and development of staff is crucial both in developed
and developing countries. It is appropriate in an extremely
sophisticated library system using the most up-to-date computer methods
and equally appropriate in a library system that may only recently have
been established.
Castelyn (2007) added that it must be recognized that libraries are
labour-intensive and that staff are an expensive commodity, usually
taking up to 60% of the budget in the form of salaries, which represents
a sizeable amount of public or private expenditure. The motivation of
staff and the efficient organization of a library system are two of the
primary functions of a good library manager and should involve the
proper use of training. It is also an economic necessity to have staff
fully operational as soon as possible. Staff training and development
should therefore be orientated towards the libraries' needs and
services but should not ignore the requirements of the individual member
of staff, either for the present or the future.
Castelyn (2007) was also of the view that a trained staff able to
exploit the book stock means a more satisfied readership at all levels.
The readers must be able to feel confident in the member of staff who
may be dealing with them. This confidence means that readers will return
again to borrow books and to ask for information from the library staff.
Here the knowledge of the individual staff member plays an important
part, for the staff, even if they have only a basic education, must be
knowledgeable about the tasks they perform on a daily basis and must
have a sound understanding of the organization in which they are
working. Training and development will enable them to participate more
intelligently in the work of the library. They must know why they are
asked to operate certain procedures and what will happen if they make
mistakes.
According to Mathis and Jackson (2000) training is the process by
which employees acquire capabilities to aid in the achievement of
organizational goals, hence the need for training and development
activity to help in the achieving of the goals of academic libraries
which is the total satisfaction of the clients. In a limited sense,
training provides employees with specific, identifiable knowledge, and
skills for use in their present jobs. Sometimes a distinction is drawn
between training and development, with development being broader in
scope and focusing on individual gaining new capabilities, useful for
both present and future jobs. However, for the purpose of this work
training and development are adopted as one activity.
According to McClelland (2002), the significance and value of
training and development has long been recognized. The exponential
growth in technology with its effect on the economy and society at
large, the need for training and development is more pronounced than
ever especially in social institutions like the academic library.
Training and development in the most simplistic definition, is an
activity that changes people's behaviour. Increased productivity is
often said to be the most important reason for training and development.
Training and development is essential not only to increase productivity
but also to motivate and inspire workers by letting them know how
important their jobs are and giving them all the information they need
to perform those jobs of which librarian and library staff are not
exempted (McClelland, 2002).
Olaniyan and Ojo (2008) added that training and development can
solve a variety of manpower problems, which militate against optimal
productivity in institutions. These can be summarized as increasing
productivity, increasing the quality of work and raise morale of
personnel, helping to develop new skills, knowledge, understanding and
attitudes for work, using rightly new tools and machines, processes and
methods, reducing waste, accidents, turnover, lateness, absenteeism, and
other overhead costs in organizations, implement new or changed policies
or regulations, fighting obsolescence in skills and technologies,
Increasing performance which meets the standard of performance for the
job, developing replacements schedules, preparing people for
advancement, improving manpower deployment and ensuing continuity of
leadership and ensuing the survival and growth of the institutions in
all times (Olaniyan & Ojo, 2008).
Third world academic libraries are not 'islands' in the
information world. There is the need for them to move with the rest of
the world, in the provision of quality information. As stated by an
Australian born voluntary librarian, "we have to come into the
world of technology sometime, otherwise we shall be left behind by the
big countries" (Partridge, 1998).
According to Nabuyanda (2006), nowadays librarians and library
staff task have broadened with added responsibilities placed on them by
the demands of the diverse research needs of the clients. They are
challenged to be open minded and approachable to queries while knowing
how to satisfy the information needs of the client. A lot of current
issues including information on HIV/AIDs, terrorism, environmental
matters, politics and sport will be brought to their attention. Much as
each individual library surveyed has their own unique features of
information provided to the users depending on the type of courses
provided, there are a lot of similarities in the challenges being faced.
From the assertions above, it is obvious that training and development,
no matter the level of the staff in an institution or organization is an
important tool to enhance the performance level and increase
productivity as well as coping with new challenges of which staff of
Polytechnic libraries are key stakeholders. The absence of training and
development activity usually tend to affect the quality of service,
professional career development and seemingly affecting productivity in
the libraries including the Polytechnic libraries.
2. Statement of Problem
For the library personnel to be able to cope with the changing
trends of teaching, learning and research, there is the need for
relevant training and development activity on regular basis. It is
basically accepted that training and development has come to stay in
most institutions, Polytechnic libraries in Ghana are no exception.
Academic libraries have usually been seen as custodians of books and
journals for the academia but the challenge that is arising out of
globalization and information technology is that the third world
academic library has to provide up-to-date information which will
benefit the clients both now and in the future (Cotta-Schonberg, 2005).
It is therefore appropriate for all academic libraries to upgrade their
staff to enable them fit into the global world. This means that there is
the need for adequate training and development programmes in all
academic libraries including the Polytechnic libraries through
thoughtful and well defined needs analysis. However, it seems there is
lack of training and development programmes in most Polytechnic
libraries in Ghana. This may affect the delivery of quality services,
professional career development and seemingly affecting productivity in
the Polytechnic libraries in Ghana. This implies that when the personnel
of the library are exposed to training and development activity, they
can contribute their quota to the process of teaching, learning and
research because they would be abreast with current trends in the
profession. It was for these challenges that the researcher decided to
conduct this study to assess the training and development programmes in
the Polytechnic libraries in Ghana. Furthermore, the literature reviewed
indicated that most of the researches (Yeboah & Antwi, 2001; Alemna,
2001; Abba & Dawha, 2009; Ajidahun, 2007; Adanu, 2006), conducted
were all based on training and development of the library staff in
Universities. It is against this background that the researchers
consider it important to conduct a study of this kind in the Polytechnic
libraries in Ghana.
3.0 Purpose of the Study
The purpose of the research is to assess the training and
development programmes in Polytechnic libraries in Ghana with a view of
identifying possible problems and making the necessary recommendations
for their resolution.
4.0 Objectives of the Study
The specific objectives of the study were as follows:
i. To find out the availability of training and development
policies in Polytechnic libraries.
ii. To find out the training and development needs of Polytechnic
libraries
iii. To find out the frequency of training and development of
Polytechnic library staff.
iv. To ascertain whether the Polytechnic libraries face any
challenges in the training and development of staff.
v. To make recommendations based on the findings of the study.
5.0 Research Questions
The under listed research questions guided the study in achieving
the objectives.
i. Are there any training and development policies in Polytechnic
libraries?
ii. What are the specific training and development needs of
Polytechnic library staff?
iii. Is the organization of training and development frequent for
Polytechnic library staff?
iv. What are the challenges of training and development programmes
in Polytechnic libraries?
6.0 RELATED LITERATURE REVIEW
6.1 Training and Development Activity
A lot of relevant researches have been conducted in this area
locally and internationally. Professional development for academic
librarians and library staff fulfills a need for the continuing
acquisition of knowledge and competencies that has not been met by
either formal education or on-the-job-training. This need is motivated
by both the "technological imperative" thus the rapid
technological change that characterizes contemporary academic libraries,
and by the element that librarians and information workers share with
other professionals, that they are compensated for what they know as
well as for what they do (Pan & Hovde, 2010).
This means that training and development of librarians and library
staff is of great importance especially in this era of Information
Technology (IT). Employees need training and development for various
purposes. Abifarin (1997) opines that staff is an important factor in
motivation. If we are able to engage personnel through training and
development, the effect on them and the library is endless. According to
Ugonna (1998) there is the need for academic libraries to have library
trainee programmes like short courses for new skills as well as visits
to other libraries and swap programmes. As a matter of concern this will
equip the library staff to be able to deliver as expected in all aspects
of their work.
In a study conducted by Yeboah and Antwi (2001), they echoed the
importance of motivation and the need for Heads/Directors to take
interest in motivating their subordinates. The inference was that
training and development must form a core motivational tool to develop
the library staff especially those in the Polytechnic libraries in order
to make them ready to face the changing nature of their clients and
provide excellent services. Owusu-Acheaw's (2008) study revealed
that, there were a number of training and development programmes
available in Polytechnics but not many of the library staff have
benefitted. With regards to this, training and development which is a
tool of motivation should be implemented on regular bases.
6.2 Training and Development Policies
Ezeani (2008) confirmed that most academic libraries do not have
staff development policies and those who do are not critically dedicated
to it. The conclusion from the study was that, it affects the growth and
continuing education programmes of many librarians and library staff. In
addition, for continuing education to be properly tackled, libraries
should of necessity have a well articulated staff development programme
which will guide the building of capacities in relevant and needed areas
in the library. The fact is visible because without regular training and
development the individual cannot perform as expected in the profession.
Tiamiyu (1997) opines that, professional and career development
paths for entrants to the library profession are attractive within
individual libraries and in the library industry. This, he added, will
reassure library professionals, of a well planned profession and
industry devoid of frustrations. For career growth, training and
development is of great importance and should be tackled by the human
resource experts in institutions including Polytechnic library
management.
6.3 Frequency of Organizing Training and Development Activity
The frequency of organizing training and development is crucial in
the development of any academic library throughout the world. The debate
now is whether the regular organization of such training and development
results in the expected increase in productivity in institutions or
organizations including Polytechnic libraries in Ghana. Abba and Dawha
(2009), citing the National Universities Commission (NUC) (1996)
emphasizes the significance of staff training and development in
University/Academic libraries. The NUC stipulates that, the
Librarian/Head should ensure regular training and development of all the
library staff. He/she should encourage illiterate staff, if any, to go
for adult literacy classes to ensure their retention and progress in a
'book' institution such as the University (Academic) library.
The Librarian/Head should also encourage all the library staff,
where appropriate, to go for higher education. Library Assistants for
library Diploma; graduates for Master's and Doctorate degrees;
short course for administrative and secretarial staff. Sponsorship for
any training and development should be based on good performance of the
library staff. The Librarian/Head should equally encourage the library
staff to participate in continuing education programmes. The library
staff should be sponsored for conferences, seminars and workshops.
However, they should seriously be encouraged to participate actively by
presenting papers at these gatherings (Abba & Dawha (2009).
Nairis and Ukpere (2010) indicated concerns that signing of
training and development agreement is indispensable because it will
motivate the staff to stay on in most institutions. More recently Abba
and Dawha (2009), in their studies on assessment of personnel training
needs in the Ibrahim Babangida library, concluded on the basis that
there was a greater need for on-the-job training and informal training
than for formal education. Inadequate funding was nominated by 100% of
the 40 respondents as the key factor militating against the provision of
adequate training, with 62.5% of the respondents also noting the lack
of written training policy.
In the work of Nairis and Ukpere (2009), they confirmed that
tertiary educational institutions' key ambition is to generate and
disseminate knowledge; therefore, they should effectively implement
policies such as the human resource code for staff development training
in order to enhance the skills and knowledge of staff members, in order
to achieve their goals. In addition, the findings of the research
revealed that staff members are sent on development programmes on their
own requests, provided that they meet stipulated requirements to be
eligible for a scholarship, loan and study aid. This shows that there
are no laid down policies of training and development for the library
staff in general.
Ajidahun (2007) indicated in a research study that, the level of
professional training in information technology received by the
professional and para-professional library staff in Nigerian University
libraries is generally inadequate as shown by the results of the
research. Greater hard work must be made therefore by University
libraries in Nigeria to provide adequate training programmes in
information technology and other related subjects for the librarians and
library staff, especially professional staff, in order to make them
relevant and adequate to face the technological challenges of the
twenty-first century. Each University library should therefore begin to
initiate its own staff development policy which will involve among other
things, a definition of goals and objectives, an assessment of staff
strengths and weaknesses, a development of long and short range training
and development programmes, the implementation and evaluation of the
effectiveness of the programme.
6.4 Specific Training and Development Needs
Similarly, Odini (1999) was of the view that, a changing
environment in which social, political, economic and other pressures all
differ in an irregular manner requires arrangement to keep a stable
organization. If librarians and information workers are to be concerned
with serving their community effectively in a changing information
environment, more time must be spent in planning their training and
development programmes, taking into account all of the environmental
factors.
Alemna (1998) argues that, a sound library education is paramount
of importance to the image and prestige of the library profession. This
is because a profession like librarianship is not fixed but vibrant due
to the fast changing nature of the world as well as the information
needs of our clients. Alemna (2001) proposed that, there should be
improvement in the various types of training and development programmes
with a considerable support from the government, employer and change in
the magnitude of organizing continuing education especially from the
Ghana Library Association (GLA) as well as the Department of Information
Studies, University of Ghana. Training and development is important for
the maintenance of the human resource base of the organization and must
be viewed as an integral part of the core organizational strategy,
rather than an ad hoc operation.
Antwi (2002) opines that, due to the shifting role of libraries and
the impact on Information Technology (IT) on library service delivery
demand that staffs of academic libraries where students, staff and
researchers seek information for their studies should regularly advance
their knowledge on new developments through continuing education and
training. Lagging behind in area of IT would affect the delivery of the
library staff especially in sections of cataloguing, classification,
reference services, circulation and interlibrary loan services.
To ascertain findings from other studies Adanu (2006), also
undertook a study in order to determine the level of support for
continuous professional development in five state-owned Universities in
Ghana. The survey and interviews conducted, with employees of the five
Universities, revealed that, the University library environment in Ghana
is to some extent conducive to continuous professional development
activities. There is however, need to develop more formal policy
development in this regard. There was also a high level of recognition
by respondents that the employing institution and the individual staff
member share liability for identifying and meeting continuous
professional development needs.
6.5 Challenges of Training and Development Activity
Abba and Dawha (2009) indicated that, inadequate funding was the
leading factor which represented 100%, lack of written training and
development policies was the next; this also represented 62.5%, followed
by lack of personnel which also represented 50% and lastly shortage of
staff which was 37.5%. In another discourse Osei (1996), on professional
staff development in academic library argues that there are many
problems which militate against professional staff development in spite
of its dignified objectives. These include the problems of finance,
time, individual needs and the inability to fulfill rising expectations.
Professional staff development is quite often thought of as an
optional extra which should be considered only when there are buoyant
finances and, hence, in the face of economic stringency, resources for
professional staff development are grudgingly allocated. In an academic
library which operates on minimum staffing, the problem arises as to
whether a professional staff member could be spared from a service point
to attend a course, a seminar or a workshop. From the assertion of both
authors it is worthwhile to stress that finance is a core militating
factor as far as training and development is concerned (Osei, 1996). In
the work of Ukwoma and Akanwa (2008) on human resource development in
Nigerian academic libraries, it came to light from the survey that
inadequate funding is the highest militating factor against training and
development programmes followed by the lukewarm attitude and lack of
support from the management as well as lack of written training and
development policies among others. These represented 100% and 77.7% of
the total respondents respectively.
7.0 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The researchers employed the mixed method approach as the study
design. The study was a cross-sectional survey in which data from a
sample that was drawn from a predetermined population was collected at
just one point in time and the time taken to collect all of the data and
information desired was spread over a number of weeks. The population of
the study was the Librarians/Heads and Library Staff (Senior Members,
Senior Staff as well as Junior Staff of the Polytechnic Libraries). The
Senior Members consisted of Professionals who hold Post-Graduate Degrees
in Library Studies or Information Studies, Senior Staff were made up of
Paraprofessionals that is, those who hold Certificate, Diploma or Degree
in Library Studies or Information Studies and Junior Staff were the
Non-professionals, which was made up of library clerks with SSCE and
other Clerical background excluding cleaners and laborers. The total
number of the population was one hundred and forty-four (144) as at the
time the study was conducted. The table below shows a summary of the
categories of staff who were sampled.
Table 1 Population of the study
Polytechnics Heads/Senior Senior staff Junior staff Total
members
Accra 2 3 11 17
Kumasi 2 5 13 20
Takoradi 2 6 9 17
Sunyani 1 10 9 20
Tamale 1 2 10 13
Ho 1 4 12 17
Koforidua 1 10 3 14
Cape Coast 1 4 9 14
Wa 1 2 2 4
Bolgatanga 1 5 2 8
Total 13 51 80 144
Source: (Human Resource Department of the Polytechnics, 2013)
The population was made up of thirteen Professional Librarians,
fifty-one Para-Professional Librarians and eighty Non-Professional
Librarians. The researchers considered all as the sample size because it
was manageable within the timeframe for this study. The Polytechnics
were Accra, Kumasi Takoradi, Ho, Tamale, Sunyani, Koforidua, Cape Coast,
Wa and Bolgatanga. A questionnaire and an interview schedule were used
to collect data for this study. The relevance of the combination of
these two main instruments was to apply the concept and principle
underlying mixed methods approach.
The researchers pre-tested the questionnaire and interview schedule
among colleagues who are staff of other academic libraries. After that,
the necessary corrections were made before the distribution of the
questionnaire and conduct of the interview. The questionnaires and
interview schedule were administered by the researchers and five trained
research assistants at the various campuses of the Polytechnics during
working hours with the help of representatives. The Polytechnic
libraries which were far from reach had their questionnaire and
interview schedules sent to them and received through e-mails. The study
was conducted in July 2013. The interview schedule was used purposively
to solicit information from the Librarians/Heads. Though initially it
was difficult to book appointments to enable the researchers interview
the Librarians/Heads, this interview was successfully conducted.
The data collected through the administration of the questionnaire
was analyzed with the use of Statistical Package for Social Sciences
(SPSS). The SPSS was used because it is easier to define variables,
input data and generate outputs or reports (reference).Variables were
coded in the variable view and the answered questionnaires (data) also
entered in the data view to generate the required reports. In addition,
qualitative content analysis was used to analyze the information
obtained from interviewing the various Librarians/Heads of the
Polytechnic libraries. The results were organized according to the
objectives of the research. The analysis was mainly quantitative
supported with qualitative analysis to present the results of the study.
8.0 DISCUSSIONS
From Table 2, the results obtained indicated that, out of the total
respondents of 110, 12(10.9%) fell within the age range of 20-30 years,
70(63.6%) were within the age range of 31-40, but 19(17.2%) were within
41-50 age group, and 9(8.2%) were within the age distribution of 51-60.
In conclusion, it can be said that majority of the library staff in the
Polytechnics were within their youthful age representing 70(63.6%) which
was more than half of the total respondents.
From Table 2, it can be observed that, 6(5.5%) out of the total
respondents of 110, were employed between 1991-1993, 11(10.0%) were
employed between 1994-1996, 16(14.5%) were employed between 1997-1999,
and 26(23.6%) were also employed from 2000-2002. Again, 27(24.5%) were
employed within the years 2003-2005, 18(16.4%) were recruited between
the years 2006-2008 and finally 6(5.5%) were employed from 2009 to 2011.
At a quick glance it can be deduced that, the between years 1997 and
2008, the employment rate of the libraries in the Polytechnics was
considerably higher representing 27(24.5%). This meant that a lot of
training and development programmes should be going on which should lead
to career progressions of staff.
From Table 3, data collected indicated that, out of the total
respondents of 110, 10(9.1%) were Professionals, 59(53.6%) were
Para-professionals and 41(37.3%) were Non-professionals. It is
worthwhile to say that minority of the library staff in the Polytechnic
libraries were Professionals as against a majority of Para-professionals
and Non-Professionals. The Para-professionals and Non-Professionals
represented more than half of the total staff strength in the various
Polytechnics libraries. This meant that the Polytechnic libraries must
get most of their library staff involved in the training and development
programmes available if any.
From Figure 3, out of the 110 respondents, 9(8.2%) were Masters
Degree holders in Information Studies or Library Studies 36(32.7%) had
Degrees in Information Studies, 33(32.7%) held Diploma in Librarianship
and 26(23.6%) were SSCE graduates and finally 6(5.4%) were professionals
from other fields. It could be concluded that only a few of the library
staff in Polytechnics were Masters Degree holders. This represented
9(8.2%) out of the total respondents. It is therefore imperative for the
Polytechnic libraries to encourage majority of their staff to upgrade
themselves to be able to meet the challenges of the changing role of the
modern librarian and information worker especially in the Polytechnics.
Awareness of training and development policy
From Figure 4, it can be seen that, out of the 110 respondents,
52(47.3%) responded "yes" when asked of the awareness of
training and development policies in the Polytechnics as a whole, whilst
49(44.5%) responded in the negative. On the same issue 9(8.2%) said they
"don't know". The results show that some of respondents
were at least aware that there existed training and development in all
the Polytechnics. A follow up question as to whether the libraries had
their own staff development policies was asked, the confirmation was
that the Polytechnic libraries did not have their own training and
development policy. The results showed the libraries did not have
training and development policies. This revelation supported the finding
from the study of Ezeani (2008) who was of the view that, most academic
library staff does not have staff development policies and those who do
are not seriously committed to it. The conclusion was that, it affected
the growth and continuing education programmes of many librarians and
library staff.
Table 5, indicated that out of the total respondents of 110,
34(30.9%) indicate not aware when asked if the policy of their various
Polytechnic has been reviewed, 58(52.7%) expressed the opinion that it
was reviewed some time ago and 18(16.4%) indicated they were not sure.
It could be concluded that the various Polytechnics had training and
development policies but it had not been revised for some time now. All
the Head Librarians interviewed agreed to this revelation.
From Table 6, the results show that, out of total respondents of
110, 9(8.2%) mentioned Cataloguing and Classification, 30(27.3%) said
Reference Services, 12(10.9) said Circulation, 53(48.2%) preferred
E-library (ICT) and 4(3.6%) were of the view that, Acquisition and
Collection Development, whilst 2(1.8%) said others when they were asked
to indicate the section which needed training and development most. The
Head Librarians interviewed also echoed a similar view. The indication
was that, a considerable number of the respondents think that, staff at
the E-library (ICT) section needed the most training and development
activity. The deduction is that the profession is now changing at a fast
rate and therefore the staff must also be trained to meet the demands of
the system, especially ICT in the area of provision of databases,
library facilities, and library software among others, the researcher
agrees with Odini's (1999) findings that, the changing information
environment requires a workforce which is familiar with the emerging
information and communication technologies (ICT) on which the brave new
world of information will depend and that, Librarians and library staff
must arm themselves with the necessary skills in the use of various
software packages, the Internet, CD-ROMs and of course traditional
printed resources.
Results of Table 7, show that, out of the total respondents of 110,
22(20.0%) were satisfied with the level of training and development
because it was systematic, 77(70.0. %) were not satisfied with the
programmes because it was irregular, whilst 11(10.0%) also indicated
that they "did not know". The view of the Head Librarians
interviewed were not different but added that most Polytechnics do not
do need assessment to guide them. It is significant to conclude that
most of the respondents were not satisfied with training and development
because it was irregular. This finding is in line with Ugonna (1998) who
believes that every institution has a duty to further the development
and growth of its members once it has recruited them and it must be
frequent and systematic. Ugonna (1998) added that, there is the need for
academic libraries to have library trainee programmes, short courses for
new skills, as well as visits to other libraries and exchange programmes
on regular basis.
From Figure 5, out of the total respondents of 110, 18(16.4%) said
none, 40(36.4%) said once, 29(26.4%) said twice, 13(11.8%) indicated
thrice, 7(6.3 %) said four times, 3(2.7%) mentioned more than four
times. The Head Librarians concur to the revelation of the library staff
when interviewed. In conclusion, it could be ascertained that training
and development programmes were organized either once or twice judging
from the results. Abba & Dawha (2009) Pan & Hovde (2010) all
share the view that for training and development to be frequent, there
is the need to make all the requisite supports whether administrative,
funds, logistics and facilities available so that staff may be well
informed in advance and also prepare towards it.
In rating the challenges of training and development programmes,
Figure 6, shows that, out of the total respondents of 110, 31(28.2%)
indicated that the hindrance was management attitude, 16(14.5%)
expressed that the obstacle was staff attitude, 50(45.5%) mentioned lack
of finance as the challenge, 9(8.2%) indicated the problem was lack of
facilities and 4(3.6%) attributed the challenge to time schedules of
such programmes. However, the Heads contacted on the issue accepted the
there were challenges but management attitude dominates. In conclusion
it can be stated that, lack of finance dominated the challenges which
represented 50(45.5%) of the total respondents. The researcher agrees
with what, Abba and Dawha, (2009) & Ukwoma and Akanwa, (2008) found
in their studies. They identified a lot of factors militating against
training and development such as inadequate funding, management
attitude, lack of written training and development policy lack of
experts, time schedules and attitude of staff among others. Inadequate
funding and lack of written training and development policy (staff
development policy) and management attitude were rated highest in all.
9.0 CONCLUSION
Training and development programmes are vital issues of career
progression of every employee in an institution. In order to provide
quality services to the users of libraries especially in academic
environment, librarians and library staffs need to commit themselves to
continuous learning and for that matter training and development
activities. Since Polytechnics are stakeholders in the tertiary
educational system, it is laudable for the Polytechnic libraries to
engage their staff in training and development activities on regular
basis to enable them support teaching, learning and research among the
academia. Besides, it is imperative for the Polytechnic libraries in
Ghana to fix and position themselves in the tenets of a performance
technology model which is systematic and set of methods of increasing
productivity in order to meet the changing and sophisticated needs of
users in the academic libraries.
10.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
The library acts as the pivot of teaching and learning as well as
research in every academic institution. Staff development should
therefore be paramount in order to make the staff proactive in their
daily routines. Based on the findings of this study, the under listed
recommendations are proposed: Heads/Directors with the assistance of the
human resource units in the Polytechnics should educate the library
staff on the existence of staff development policies especially during
orientation of new staff and must be on regular basis. Management of the
Polytechnics should equally inform library staff of any changes in the
existing staff development policies, in order to make staff abreast with
issues of training and development of their institutions. Considerably,
a unit could be established at the library to execute issues of training
and development. Apart from that, management of the Polytechnic
libraries should also try as much as possible to organize in-service
training on staff development programmes for library staff. Besides,
copies of abridged form of training and development policies could
equally be circulated to all units and departments where necessary, for
workers to have access to them.
Since users of most academic libraries have become more
sophisticated, it is imperative that library staffs are given regular
ICT training in order for them to acquire hands-on- skills to better
satisfy the information needs of clients. ICT skills will also help in
the routine duties such as cataloging and classification, indexing,
circulation, charging and discharging of materials as well as library
management in totality. Management of the Polytechnics should be
encouraged to allocate a separate budget for library staff every year.
This must however be adequate in order to cater for all issues of
training and development especially for in-house training and
development programmes, because it has direct impact on delivery of
quality services in the library.
Management of the various institutions should liaise with the
Heads/Directors from time to time on how to conduct systematic training
and development programmes. This is because they would be in the best
position to give feedback on the performance of staff. Hence their
training and development programmes must be timely. Apart from that,
experienced librarians should be consulted on regular basis for the
organization of training and development programmes because they are a
store of professional knowledge.
It is time all librarians and library staff changed their attitudes
towards pursuing career advancement and participate fully in all
training and development programmes in the quest to develop. The
organization of training and development programmes should be designed
to meet the professional career advancement of library staff. It must
also be communicated to the respondents with respect to venue, time,
duration, cost and other related important items on time.
All library staff should be encouraged to be registered members of
professional associations such as the GLA (Ghana Library Association) so
as to benefit from the activities of such associations. Besides,
management of Polytechnics should be encouraged to develop their skills
in training and development so that they can inculcate it into their
training and development assessment needs. The issue of proper planning
of training and development programmes should also be taken into
consideration, since it will mean all anticipated challenges are taken
care of.
REFERENCES
Asante, E. (2013) Training and Development in Polytechnic Libraries
in Ghana. (Unpublished Mphil Thesis), University of Ghana, Legon.
Abba, T. & Dawha, E.M.K. (2009). Assessment of Personnel
Training Needs in the Ibrahim Babangida Library. Federal University of
Technology. Nigeria. Library Philosophy and Practice, available at:
http://unllib.unl.edu/LPP/abba2.htm (Accessed on12/12/11).
Abifarin, A. (1997). Motivating Staff in Nigerian University
Libraries. Library Management18, (3), 124-128.
Adanu, S. A. (2007) CPD in State-Owned Universities in Ghana.
Library Management, 28, (6/7), 292-305.
Aina, L. O. (2004). Library and Information Science Text for
Africa. Ibadan: Third World Information Services Ltd, p 339.
Ajidahun, C. O. (2007) Training, Development and Education of
Library Manpower in Information Technology in University Libraries in
Nigeria. World Libraries, 17, 85-99.
Alemna, A. A. (1998) Education and Training of the future Librarian
in Ghana. Library Career Development, 6, (1), 7.
Alemna, A. A. (2001) Perception of Continuing Education in
Librarianship in Ghana. New Library World, 102, (1160/1161), 44-47.
Babbie, E. (2005). The Basics of Social Research. 3rd ed, Belmont:
Thomson Wadsworth,
Castelyn, M. (2007) Training and Developing Staff: The training
functions in libraries. UNESCO: New York. pp 1-5.
Chaudhary, M. Y. (2001) Continuing Professional Education of
Librarians Working in the University of Pakistan and Azad Jammu and
Kashmir. INSPEL. 35, 67-73.
Cotta-Schonberg, M. (2005). Drivers and Directions of Academic
Library Development 2005. Paper presented to the European Business
Schools Librarians' group (EBSLG) at its annual general meeting.
http.library.uu.nl/publish/articles/00130/index.html) Accessed on
10/01/12.
Creswell, J.W. (2006) Understanding Mixed Methods Research.
Thousand Oaks.CA: Sage,
Ezeani, C. N. (2008) Gender as a Determinant of Job Satisfaction of
Academic Librarians in Nigeria. Ghana Library Journals 20, (2), .61.
Fraenkel, J. R. & Wallen, N. E. (2003). How to Design and
Evaluate Research in Education, 5th ed. Boston: McGraw Hill, pp117-119.
Gravetter, F. J. & Forzano, L. B. (2006). Research Methods forS
the Behavioral Sciences 2nd ed, Belmont: Wadsworth, pp 117-119, 485.
Havener, W. M., & Stolt, W. A. (1994). The Professional
Development Activities of Academic Librarians: Does Institutional
Support makes a Difference? College and Research Libraries, 55, (1),
26-36. http://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/lib_fac_pubs/44 Retrieved on
21/12/12.
Kumar, K. (2003) Library Manual. Vikas Publishing House PVT Ltd:
New Delhi. Pp 4-6.
Kumekpor, T. K. B. (2002). Research Methods and Techniques of
Social Research. Accra: Sonlife, pp117-118.
Mathis, R. L. & Jackson, J.L.(2004.) Human Resource Management
10th ed. London: Thomson-Learning, pp 217-234.
McClelland, S. D. (2002). A Training Needs Assessment for the
United Way of Dun County Wisconsin. (Unpublished Msc thesis). Available
at : www2.uwstout.edu/eontent/lib/thesis/2002/mcclellands:pdf Accessed
on 15/12/11.
Ministry of Education (1993). White Paper on the Reforms to the
Tertiary Education System. Accra: Available at
www.tig.net/pub/accra/papers/ts08. Accessed on 5/01/12.
Nabuyanda, M.M. (2006). The Academic Librarian in a Developing
Society: Challenges and Prospects of Retooling Academic Libraries.
Zambia: National Institute of Public Administration. Retrieved on
12/02/12.
Naris, N. S. & Ukpere, I. W (2009). Effectiveness of an HR
Code: Staff Development and Training at the Polytechnic of Namibia.
Business Papers and Reports. Paper 8, 25.
Naris, N. S. & Ukpere, I. W. (2010). Developing a Retention
Strategy for Qualified Staff at the Polytechnic of Zambia. Journal of
Business Management .4, (6),1078 1084.
Odini, C. (1999). Training and Development of Skills in a Changing
Information Environment Library Management, 20, (2), 100-104.
Olaniyan. A. & Ojo, L. B. (2008). Staff Development: A Vital
Tool for Organizational Effectiveness. European Journal of Scientific
Research, 24, (3), 326-331.
Osei, I. (1996) Professional Development in Academic libraries: the
UST Library Librarian Career Development, 7.43-50
Owusu-Acheaw, M. (2008). Motivation and Rewards in Attracting and
Retaining Library Staff in Academic Libraries: A case of some selected
Polytechnic Libraries in Ghana. Ghana Library Journal, 20, 2. p15.
Pan, J. & Hovde, K. (2010). Professional Development for
Academic Librarians: Needs , Resources, and Administrative Support.
Chinese Librarianship: an International Electronic Journal, 29. URL:
http://www.iclc.us/cliej/cl29PH.htm Paper presented to the European
Business Schools Librarians' group (EBSLG) at its annual general
meeting. http.library.uu.nl/publish/articles/00130/index.html) Accessed
on 10/01/12.
Partridge, W.G. (1988). Low Budget Librarianship: Managing
Information in Developing Countries, Libraries Association Publishing
Limited. London. .Available at: www.books googleschoar.com/library%
information science. Accessed on 5/01/12.
Tiamiyu M. A. (1997) Towards Overcoming Human Development Barrier
in Ghanaian Libraries. Ghana Library Journal, 19, 52.
Ugonna, K. (1988) Strategic Planning in Libraries: An analysis of a
Management function and Application in Library Information work. Library
management. 13, (2),15-18.
Ukwoma, S.C. & Akanwa,P.(2008) Human Resource Development in
Nigerian Academic Libraries: A Comparative Study of Universities in Imo
State,Samaru Journal of Information Studies. 8(2), 38-47.
Yeboah, P.A. & Antwi. K. (2001) Motivation and Productivity in
Academic Libraries: A Case study of University of Cape Coast. Ghana
Library Journal, 13, 10.
By
Edward Asante
Koforidua Polytechnic, Ghana
[email protected]
&
A. A. Alemna
Department of Information Studies
College of Communication and Continuous Education
University of Ghana
Edward Asante
Koforidua Polytechnic,
[email protected]
Anaba Alemna
University of Ghana
Caption: Figure 3 Educational qualifications of respondents
Caption: Figure 4 Awareness of training and development policy
Caption: Figure 5 Frequency of organizing training &
development programmes
Caption: Figure 6 Challenges of training & development
programmes
Table 2 Age of respondents
Age of Respondents Frequency Percentage
20-30 12 10.9
31-40 70 63.6
41-50 19 17.2
51-60 9 8.2
Total 110 100
Source: Field Data, 2013
Table 3 Year of employment
Year Frequency Percentage
S1991-1993 6 5.5
1994-1996 11 10.0
1997-1999 16 14.5
2000-2002 26 23.6
2003-2005 27 24.5
2006-2008 18 16.4
2009-2011 6 5.5
Total 110 100
Source: Field Data, 2013
Table 4 Current status of respondents
Status Frequency Percentage
Professionals 10 9.1
Para-professionals 59 53.6
Non-professionals 41 37.3
Total 110 100
Source: Field Data, 2013
Table 5 Review of training and development policy
Implementation of Policy Frequency Percentage
Not aware 34 10.9
Some time ago 58 52.7
Not sure 18 16.4
Total 110 100
Source: Field Data, 2013
Table 6 Needs of library staff
Needs of Library Staff Frequency Percentage
Cataloguing and 9 8.2
Classification
Reference Service 30 27.3
Circulation 12 10.9
ICT(e-library) 53 48.2
Acquisition and Collection 4 3.6
development
Others 2 1.8
Total 110 100
Source: Field Data, 2013
Table 7 Level of training & development programmes
Response Frequency Percentage
Systematic 22 20.0
Irregular 77 70.0
Don't know 11 10.0
Total 110 100
Source: Field Data, 2013
COPYRIGHT 2015 University of Idaho Library
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2015 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.