文章基本信息

标题：Evaluating Knowledge Production in Collaborative Water Governance
本地全文：下载
作者：Brent Taylor ; Rob C. de Loë ; Henning Bjornlund 等
期刊名称：Water Alternatives
印刷版ISSN：1965-0175
出版年度：2013
卷号：6
页码：42-66
出版社：Water Alternatives Association
摘要：Despite the crucial role of knowledge production in environmental decision-making, previous research provides limited practical insight into the knowledge-related outcomes that can be achieved through collaboration, or the associated determinants of success. In this multiple case study, knowledge production is analysed in a collaborative water allocation planning process in South Australia. A theoretical framework was developed and used to systematically evaluate and compare knowledge-related processes and outcome criteria across four planning catchments. Data sources included 62 semi-structured interviews, documents and personal observations. Most of the theorised outcomes were achieved across the cases&59; however, only one case had generated widespread acceptance among participants of the knowledge that was used to develop the water allocation plan. Comparing processes across the cases revealed key factors that influenced their outcomes. Ultimately, community participants across the cases had limited involvement in technical investigations, suggesting the need to re-examine expectations about the potential for joint fact-finding within collaborative processes that are limited in scope and duration and nested within broader state-driven processes.