文章基本信息

标题：Map the gap: alternative visualisations of geographic knowledge production
本地全文：下载
作者：Margath Walker ; Emmanuel Frimpong Boamah
期刊名称：Geo: Geography and Environment
电子版ISSN：2054-4049
出版年度：2017
卷号：4
期号：2
页码：n/a-n/a
DOI：10.1002/geo2.38
语种：English
出版社：John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
摘要：The main purpose of this paper is to develop a new method for visualizing knowledge production which is attentive to the multiple elements embedded in research processes. In particular, we seek to problematise the representation of scholarship indicators by depicting theoretical contributions and field sites along a spectrum, rather than as discrete points, recursively and relationally constituted. The primary aim of our visualisations is to capture text and context, and codified and tacit knowledge. First, we offer a conventional representation of the location of selected dominant critical theories in Geography, arguing that current methods reinforce ‘lopsided’ geographies of knowledge production. Normative practices of data visualisation and representation captured in our two examples privilege certain elements centred on authorship and tend to silence the contexts informing research. Second, we borrow the term and method of chromatography, a tool used in the natural sciences but here conceived in its more literal sense of ‘writing the separations’. Our ‘chromatographical’ representations attempt to unbundle components currently absorbed by formal indicators of knowledge production. Such counter mappings attempt to convey the relational aspect of research between countries imbricated in the propagation of exemplary critical geographic theories. We conclude with a discussion of the implications that the disaggregation of value has for scholars and their research.
关键词：geographies of knowledge;critical urbanism;critical GIS;scientometrics;bibliometric visualization