Midshipman price at Trafalgar.
McMaster, Juliet
WHEN I WAS WORKING in a private archive, I came across a
collectors' item that had been carefully preserved: a copy of The
Times of November 7, 1805, containing the first full public account of
the Battle of Trafalgar and the death of Admiral Nelson, in the form of
copies of dispatches to the Admiralty, "from Vice-Admiral
Collingwood, Commander in Chief of his Majesty's ships and vessels
off Cadiz" (2). The Times of those days was a simple affair of a
folded folio sheet, four pages in all. (1)
Collingwood's accounts have been mined by naval historians and
elaborated in the dozens of books on Trafalgar that came out for the
2005 centenary celebrations. But there was one small item in that issue
of The Times that has a special resonance for readers of Jane Austen,
most especially for readers of Mansfield Park. It appears on the third
page, in the bottom right corner, under the heading "NELSON'S
LAST MOMENTS," and it includes accounts of other heroes of
Trafalgar:
A midshipman, of the name of PRICE was brought into the cockpit,
with his leg cut off at the calf; he was an heroic youth of 17.
The Surgeons could not attend him at the moment. He drew out a
knife, and cut off a piece of flesh and the splinter of bone with
great composure. "I can stay," said he; "let me doctor myself."
When the surgeon attended him, it was found necessary to amputate
above the knee. He submitted to the operation without a groan. "It
is nothing at all," I thought it had been ten times worse. (2)
What a tale of courage and sangfroid! The account, with the
hero's selfless undertaking, "I can stay," surely recalls
the legend of Sir Philip Sidney; who, mortally wounded, still passed a
cup of water to a dying soldier with the words, "Thy necessity is
greater than mine." Like Sidney, this Midshipman Price was a hero
to be remembered.
To what extent can we attach this account of a historical
Midshipman Price to Jane Austen's midshipman, William Price of
Mansfield Park?
We can be sure that the Austen family would have been eager readers
of this Times report of Trafalgar, even though, to his lasting
disappointment, Frank Austen had missed the fray (Southam 95). We know
that Fanny Price's brother William, another Midshipman Price, is
also heroic, with "good principles, professional knowledge, energy,
courage, and cheerfulness" (MP 236). Moreover, if we accept
Chapman's 1808-09 dating for the action of the novel (Wiltshire
xliii), (3) William Price could well have been present at Trafalgar, for
he has been "seven years" at sea (though he would be somewhat
older than the historical midshipman's 17 years) and has
"known every variety of danger, which sea and war together could
offer" (236).
Should we understand Austen's William Price to be that heroic
midshipman Price at Trafalgar and conclude that for once Jane Austen
decided to mix history with fiction, in the manner of her great
contemporary Walter Scott? No. It's a tempting speculation, but no.
William Price at Mansfield Park, however like his historical namesake in
courage and cheerfulness, is sound of body; with the full complement of
limbs. And that's just as well, because he has a pleasure in
dancing that matches that of Austen's sailor brother Charles
(Southam 63).
I happen to have my own family connection to Trafalgar (I'm a
collateral descendant of one Midshipman Louis Fazan on board the
Achilles); so that in reading the Times report "I found my heart
moved more than wit a Trumpet," as Sidney says (32). So I like to
think that Austen too had read that report of the stoic Midshipman
Price, and that his story might have had some influence in her choice of
a name for her heroine's seafaring family.
WORKS CITED
Austen, Jane. Mansfield Park. Ed. R.W. Chapman. The Novels of Jane
Austen. London: Oxford UP, 1953.
Sidney, Philip. Sidney's Apologie for Poetrie. Ed. J. Churton
Collins. Oxford: Clarendon P, 1955.
Southam, Brian. Jane Austen and the Navy. London: Hambledon, 2000.
Wiltshire, John. "Introduction." Mansfield Park. The
Cambridge Edition of Jane Austen. Cambridge: CUP, 2005. xxv-lxxxiv.
NOTES
(1.) After hearing John Wiltshire's fine paper on the contexts
of Mansfield Park at the Tucson AGM, I provided a comment on this Times
report on a heroic Midshipman Price; and the interest it stirred made me
decide to make the information available to the readers of Persuasions.
(2.) The anomaly in punctuation at the end, where the quotation
marks close before the speech is completed, is in the original.
(3.) B. C. Southam's dating of 1812-13 for the main action of
the novel (Wiltshire xliii) would bring William Price into the navy in
the same year as Trafalgar.
Juliet McMaster, University Professor Emerita at the University of
Alberta, is the author of books on Thackeray, Trollope, and Dickens, and
of Jane Austen the Novelist. A frequent speaker at JASNA meetings, she
is also the co-editor of The Cambridge Companion to Jane Austen, and the
founder of the Juvenilia Press.