Rapid development of products using the technique of reverse engineering.
Cosma, Cristian ; Dume, Adrian ; Tulcan, Aurel 等
1. INTRODUCTION
Under the circumstances when the market competition becomes sharper
and sharper, it is natural that the companies, when fighting for
existence, use new concepts and engineering strategies. Finding the
strategies that lead to ensuring the market success, must take into
consideration the market characteristics and the way in which the goods
are made.
Essentially, these characteristics are:
* A great variety of products;
* The rapidly changing market;
* A long product life cycle;
* Difficult and costly design changing.
Traditional engineering is not good anymore (as a consequence).
This paper is meant to present new ways of improving the quality of
plastics parts, focused on two major directions:
* to create a real replica of original object;
* redesign of the products.
Reverse engineering is the opposite of forward engineering. It
takes an existing product, and creates a CAD model, for modification or
reproduction to the design aspect of the product. It can also be defined
as the process or duplicating an existing component by capturing the
components physical dimensions (Zhang, 2003).
2. METHODOLOGY PROPOSED
Originally, the Japanese used reverse engineering to improve on
competitors' products and, thus, avoid original design effort and
expense (1). Japanese success in new product development has led to
reverse engineering being considered as a design process. Many American
engineering colleges have courses in reverse engineering, focusing on
redesign instead of original design (2) as a problem-solving approach
(Raja et al., 2006)
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
3. CASE STUDY
There are several application areas of reverse engineering. It is
often necessary to produce a copy of a part, when no original drawings
or documentation are available.
3.1 Make a replica
Reverse engineering, the practice of studying an existing object to
create a replica or a model of the part, is no longer a new concept. As
the demand and popularity of Computer Aided Design (CAD) has increased,
reverse engineering is becoming a feasible technique to generate 3D
virtual replica or model of a presented physical part to bring into play
in 3D CAD and CAM. Reverse engineering starts from scanning the original
object by means of measuring devises to digitize the surface information
The part to be replicated after scanning is a hair clips (figure
2). As a result of scanning, two files will be obtained and saved in STL form.
The geometric model will be manufactured using reverse engineering
software by overlapping and alignment up the two entities (translation
and rotation) on all 6 axes. Once aligned the entities by using Booleans
operations (cross section) the geometrical model of scanned part is
obtained (figure 2).
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
3.2 Product redesign
The design of a new product must meet functional, performance and
aesthetical requirements. Once the design is approved, a geometrical
model is created, using reverse engineering techniques, for redesign or
manufacture.
[FIGURE 3 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 4 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 5 OMITTED]
Reverse engineering initiates the redesign process, wherein a
product is observed, disassembled, analyzed, tested,
"experienced," and documented in terms of its functionality,
form, physical principles, manufacturability, and assemblability.
Product which has been study is a stapler made of elements such as metal
and plastic (Otto & Wood, 1998). Figure 3 presents the existing
product.
a). Redesigning tin stamped/folded components Figure 4 presents the
original (metallic) system (left) and the virtual modified model
(right).
b). Redesigning plastic components First, the two plastic
components were scanned. These two parts were then imported to a CAD
software, where were modified both esthetically and functionally, with
the help of a module which allows operating STL files.
Note that the binding system for both plastic and tin components
was totally redesigned. Finally we get a new product, the product
presented in figure 5.
3.3 Reverse engineering for active mould parts
Reverse engineering, or digitizing a physical part, is a critical
task for any mold and pattern shop.
Part of the following case is an application for an important
company in automotive industry. For this case wanted a redesign of the
part, and the achievement of mold inserts using reverse engineering
techniques. After scanning the part and realization of finite element simulations we obtained the geometric model of the inserts mold (Yau et
al., 2008). Initial geometric model was a STL file. We use STL importer
software to transform the STL file in solid.
With the geometric model of the part can be obtained the insertions
mould (figure 6).
[FIGURE 6 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 7 OMITTED]
Finally, using rapid prototyping or traditional techniques
(electrical discharge machining) we can make the physical insertion of
the mould--figure 7 (Turc, 2003).
4. CONCLUSION
Integrating reverse engineering process together with rapid
prototyping processes and generating and processing software leads to
manufacturing something impossible little time ago: a physical model (or
it's mould) for which no technical documentation is available. This
paper presents three applications of the reverse engineering technique
in order to reduce design time for a new product, with minimal
production costs. The steps using in this combine conventional
engineering methods with modern techniques like reverse engineering and
rapid prototyping. Products with enhanced quality can be developed and
produced in a shorter period of time. The limitations of reverse
engineering is relatively high in the price of software, the user
requires high knowledge regarding geometrical modeling. Another
disadvantage is the STL format. This format was designed to give just
the amount of data in the form of meshes to operate the
Stereolithography machines, but not actual engineering data. This format
is very difficult to utilize for reverse engineering. Future research
plans are the development of a methodology as simple transformation STL
file into a file of approved by traditional CAD software.
5. REFERENCES
Ferreira, J.C. & Alves, N.F. (2003). Integration of reverse
engineering and rapid tooling in foundry technology, Journal of
Materials Processing Technology Vol.142, No.2, (November 2003) page
numbers (374-382), ISSN 0924-0136
Otto, K.N & Wood, K.L. (1998). Product Evolution: A Reverse
Engineering and Redesign Methodology, Research in Engineering Design,
Vol.10, No. 4, (December 1998) page numbers (226-243), ISSN 0934-9839
(Print) 1435-6066 (Online)
Raja, V.; Zhang, S.; Garside, J.; Ryall, C. & Wimpenny, D.
(2006). Rapid and cost-effective manufacturing of high-integrity
aerospace components, The International Journal of Advanced
Manufacturing Technology, Vol.27, No.7-8, (January 2006) page numbers
(759-773), ISSN 0268-3768 (Print) 1433-3015 (Online)
Turc, C (2003). The surveillance of the parameters of electrical
discharge machining, Academic Journal of Manufacturing Engineering, Vol.
1, No.1, (February 2003) page number (43-46), ISSN 1583-7904
Zhang, Y. (2003). Research into the engineering application of
reverse engineering technology, Journal of Materials Processing
Technology, Vol.139, No.1-3, (August 2003) page numbers (472-475), ISSN
0924-0136
Yau, H. T. & Hsu, C. Y. (2008). Generating NC tool paths from
random scanned data using point-based models, The International Journal
of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, Vol.41, No.9-10, (April 2009) page
numbers (897-907), ISSN 0268-3768 (Print) 1433-3015 (Online)