An accomplished collection from Eavan Boland.
Keating-Miller, Jennifer
EAVAN BOLAND
Domestic Violence
Manchester: Carcanet Press, 2007, 8.95 [pounds sterling]
LIKE THE METAPHORICAL cycles of time that spiral throughout each
poem, Boland's most recent volume offers carefully rendered,
muscular verse that is syncopated with tidbits of wisdom and grace,
exemplary of a well seasoned poet. As always, the thrust of
Boland's work juxtaposes Ireland's national imperatives
crossing the thresholds of suburban domestic interiors. But in these
poems Boland catalogs many of Ireland's cultural and political
permutations that jockey alongside her personal consideration of an
individual's journey into middle age.
From the opening poem, Boland doses distances between
Ireland's national narrative and the personal history of the
region's citizens. "How young we were, how ignorant, how ready
/ to think the only history was our own," she writes in the opening
poem, "Domestic Violence." Focusing on a vision of youth that
can only be articulated through hindsight, Boland's mention of
"how young we were, how ignorant" refers not only to a
newly-wed couple but a fledgling nation, emerging from years of colonial
rule with fervent efforts to assert political and cultural sovereignty,
falling to mythmaking that espouses the idea that "the only history
was our own." Crafting the domestic interior of "the
suburbs" as inextricably linked to the intimacy and almost
claustrophobic political composition of Ireland's divided island,
"Domestic Violence" cites the couple's marriage as
contemporaneous to "that season" when "suddenly our
island / broke out its old sores for all to see." Although
distanced from the "killings, killings, killings, / then
moonlight-coloured funerals/" by their "ancient twelve by
fifteen television," Boland's couple's dismay at
"what it is / is wrong in the lives of those who hate each
other" makes them no less culpable.
Joining the fate of all of Ireland's citizenry, Boland gently
demands, "if I can be safe in / the weak spring light of that
kitchen, then / why is there another kitchen, spring light / always
darkening in it and / a woman whispering to a man / over and over what
else could we have done?" in section 3 of "Domestic
Violence." Attempting to undermine the often comfortable distance
between the Republic and Northern Ireland, worlds apart in regard to
levels of violence but nonetheless fused by "its old sores for all
to see," Boland reflects on the interconnections between early
married life mad a fledgling partitioned nation's attempt to come
to terms with incessant disputes not unlike the "couple who
quarreled into the night." As she writes, "We failed our
moment or our moment failed us. / The times were grand in size and we
were small" to open final section of the poem, she quickly retracts
such rhetoric with the curt, stinging, "Why do I Write that I when
I don't believe it?" Asking her audience to join her in an
effort to come to terms with individual participation (active or
passive) in the recent history of the shared territory of "our
island," Boland's reflections betray both regret and whispers
of wisdom from lessons learned. "As for that couple did we ever /
find out who they were / and did we want to?" Boland asks in the
final stanza of the poem. The haunting answer binds the individual and
national strands at play throughout with the admittance of personal
accountability: "I think we know" Boland writes, "I think
we always knew."
While Ireland's national imperatives never wander far from
Boland's threshold, Domestic Violence also documents the personal
journey of an individual's relationship with the contradiction of
time. At once abstract and wholly concrete, poems like "Amber"
offer meditations on time and the role that memory or an "ornament
of ember / you once gave me" can play at eroding the seeming
inevitability of its passage. Contrasting images of "trees on their
hillsides, in their groves, weeping" and "a plastic gold
dropping" of amber in the early lines of the poem, Boland suggests
her amber "ornament" challenges our notions of reason that
"says ... / The dead cannot see the living. / The living will never
see the dead again." In the "sunny atmosphere" of her
present moment, Boland's amber trinket makes "collected seeds,
leaves and even small feathers" seem "as alive as they ever
were / as though the past could be present and memory itself Baltic
honey." In its crystal preservation Boland's amber bends
notions of time through the seeds, leaves and small feathers that offer
glimpses of "trees on their hillsides" from centuries, before
that may not differ drastically from our own perceptions of the past.
She describes the metaphor of memory in amber as "a chafing at the
edges of the seen, a showing off of just how much / can be kept
safe." But this preservation is of course bittersweet--the ornament
is just that. It is a trinket to remind her of someone who "on this
fine September afternoon" is "absent." Offering herself
to the unyielding pull of time--whether abstract or literal--the
poem's final Clause inextricably joins the amber ornament and the
metaphor of the poet's depiction of memory--"inside a flawed
translucence." Inevitably tainted though crystallized, in our
mind's eye, Boland's "Amber" suggests these
ornaments from our past will just have to be enough to remind us of
time, long gone by.
Whether contemplating motherhood in "Inheritance" or the
passing of her own mother in "An Elegy for my Mother in Which She
Scarcely Appears," Boland's wanderings engage the imagination
of the individual reader and the broader expanse that is Ireland in
poems like "In Coming Days." This is an accomplished
collection, demonstrating Boland's range and mastery of language
that literally speaks from and to multiple generations. In Domestic
Violence Boland Offers a weighty volume that considers and challenges
our notions of relations to nations, family, memory and time with
graceful strokes reminiscent of the image of Julie Manet that appears
in. "On This Earth," This is a significant collection of
poetry that-not only enriches the long legacy of Irish letters to which
Boland has steadily contributed in recent decades but will enrich the
lives of students, instructors and leisurely readers of poetry alike,
--University of Pittsburgh