Intertextual Pursuits: Literary Meditations in Modern Spanish Narrative. Jeanne P. Brownlow, John W. Kronik, eds. Lewisburg, Pa. / London. Bucknell University Press / Associated University Presses. 1998. 273 pages. ISBN 0-8387-5370-1.
Gerling, David Ross
Twelve essays plus a substantial introduction make up Intertextual Pursuits. The introductory article and the final essay, respectively,
define intertextuality and argue convincingly for its continuing
importance as a universal literary philosophy. Each of the eleven essays
in-between addresses a particular facet of intertextuality in modern
Spanish peninsular prose. Nevertheless, the scope of all thirteen
contributions takes in as well the cinema, opera, ethics,
historiography, feminism, religion, and even genetics.
In the introduction, "The Death and Life of
Intertextuality," editors Jeanne Brownlow and John Kronik develop a
composite definition of intertextuality, a term coined by Julia Kristeva
in the 1960s. For their purpose they enlist the aid of an impressive
group that includes, besides Kristeva, Mikhail Bakhtin, Harold Bloom,
Roland Barthes, Jacques Derrida, and Michel Foucault. The editors
determine that intertextuality is discourse and that it transcends the
mere recognition of sources and influences to embrace the
characteristics of the cybertext, where there is an "absolute and
infinite interconnectedness of things, conditions, and ideas."
In "Splitting the Reference: Postmodern Fiction and the Idea
of History in Francoist Spain," David Herzberger subsumes into the
realm of intertextuality the poststructuralist penchant to eradicate the
distinction between historiography and postmodern fiction. This
"splitting of the reference" denies historiography its special
status as exclusive truth bearer and argues that all narrative, whether
nonfiction or fiction, invents rather than presents life. Gonzalo
Navajas, in "Intertextuality and the Reappropriation of History in
Contemporary Spanish Fiction and Film," exposes the subversive
nature of Spanish cinema and literature that appropriated history during
the Franco dictatorship. He also reveals the intertextual compulsion of
Pedro Almodovar to reconfigure popular culture through parody and irony
in the film Mujeres al borde de un ataque de nervios (Eng. Women on the
Verge of a Nervous Breakdown), where he turns upside down the concept of
male dominance. Post-Foucauldian theory on the body as text evolves
smoothly into an intertextual discussion on Galdos's novel La
desheredada and female corporeality in Akiko Tsuchiya's piece
"The Female Body under Surveillance." The essay also confronts
the naturalistic underpinnings of the nineteenth-century fear of the
unfettered female and details how the protagonist of La desheredada used
her sexuality to foil male tyranny.
In "The Domestication of Don Juan in Women Novelists of
Modernist Spain" Roberta Johnson recounts how Concha Espina, Carmen
de Burgos, Sofia Casanova, and Blanca de los Rios turned the tables on
Valle- Inclan's latter-day rake, the Marquis of Bradomin, by
encoding into their narration the original axiology expressed by Tirso
de Molina and Jose Zorrilla apropos of Don Juan. The final essay, Harold
Boudreau's "Memes: Intertextuality's Minimal
Replicators," significantly brings the entire book to the threshold
of the new millennium in that it equates cultural units of information,
"memes," with genes. His cutting-edge article puts
intertextual theory into practice by melding harmoniously genetics and
literary criticism, areas of thought hitherto considered unrelated by
most literary theorists.
Intertextual Pursuits is more than a critical approach to the
modern belles lettres of Spain. It is mind-expanding in the tradition of
books of ideas and removes Spanish literature from its spatial and
temporal boundaries by thrusting it into the flux of interconnected
humanistic discourse.
David Ross Gerling
Sam Houston State University