文章基本信息

标题：Curse or blessing? Local elites in Joint Forest Management in India’s Shiwaliks
本地全文：下载
作者：Kulbhushan Balooni ; Jens Friis Lund ; Chetan Kumar 等
期刊名称：International Journal of the Commons
电子版ISSN：1875-0281
出版年度：2010
卷号：4
期号：2
页码：707-728
语种：English
出版社：Igitur, Utrecht Publishing and Archiving Services
摘要：This article suggests that local elites play an instrumental role – either with positive or negative consequences – in shaping struggles for power over processes and outcomes of participatory forest management interventions, when implemented in communities characterized by social hierarchies. We show how the contrasting outcomes of joint forest management in two case study villages cannot be attributed to institutional reform, but appear to be caused largely by differences in the role assumed by local elites. The evidence indicates that institutional reform itself does not guarantee changes in the actual management of natural resources. Rather, vested interests at the local level and among State actors may continue to shape events while working within or beyond the new institutional landscape. On the basis of the results of our case studies, the article poses the hypothesis that a network theory of social capital could be a useful way of analyzing such diverse outcomes of similar institutional reforms implemented in relatively similar communities. We conclude by arguing that attempts at institutional reform at the level of the community in hierarchical societies should proceed with modest expectations, and an eye for the incentives facing local elites and the implementing and facilitating State actors.
关键词：Forest; local elite; state; village institutions; governance; power